Ground
Zero L.A.
Low Wages Put L.A. at the Hot Center of a National Hotel
Workers Union Fight
City Beat & Valley Beat - September 23, 2004
By Bobbi Murray
The
international hotel workers union moved closer to the perfect
storm last week after employees working without a contract
since April voted in San Francisco, Washington, D.C., and
Los Angeles to authorize a strike. A walk out in three cities
by almost 10,000 housekeepers, cooks, room service workers,
and others who keep hotels humming could be crippling to the
industry. The vote is a gloves-off gesture in a contract fight
that started out tense in the spring and has only increased
in acrimony.
In
Los Angeles, 75 percent of some 2,800 members of the hotel
workers union, UNITE HERE, turned out to vote on September
13, and 83 percent voted to authorize a strike. Ninety-two
percent of the membership had already rejected the employers'
final offer on July 1 after three and a half months of negotiations.
Management,
too, is ready to rumble. A compact among the nine Los Angeles
hotels that make up the Hotel Employers Council - operated
by such chains as Hilton, Starwood, Hyatt, and Marriott -
calls on all to lock out workers if one hotel is struck, and
extracts a fine of tens of thousands of dollars a day from
any hotel that doesn't comply. A lockout was only narrowly
averted on August 13. And last week, the downtown Wilshire
Grande locked out laundry workers represented by a different
union after their contract expired; UNITE HERE refrained from
striking in solidarity, but the signal sent was duly noted.
Both
sides insist they don't want a strike, but both are gearing
up. Reports of replacement hiring abound, including what appeared
to be a training session for some 200 replacement workers
at the St. Regis over the weekend. Fred Muir, a spokesman
for the employers' council, is unable to say just how many
of the nine member hotels were doing the same. "I can
say that all of these hotels have some kind of contingency
plan and have had them for many, many months," he says.
The
union, meanwhile, is doing all it can to vanquish the specter
of the recent failed grocery workers strike that had picketers
on 24-hour-a-day strike lines for four and a half months,
only to be forced to cave in to many management demands.
UNITE
HERE officials say that the hotel struggle is different because
of the union's level of preparation. Grocery workers were
not positioned to harness the goodwill of community members
who refused to cross picket lines, while the hotel workers
have been building community support around the current negotiations
for over a year. They have, in fact, been cultivating support
among low-wage and union workers as part of a decade-long
strategy. Los Angeles has the lowest rate of hotel unionization
among the three affected cities, and has had to adapt by building
community ties to add to its clout.
The
low unionization rate makes L.A. ground zero in the national
fight; unionized hotel workers here earn far less than those
in cities like New York, where 85 percent of hotels are organized
and a housekeeper makes around $18 an hour to her L.A. counterpart's
$11. Labor observers predict that hotel management will try
to leverage the advantage of a less unionized workforce.
One
of the not-so-secret weapons in the union's community-support
strategy is the Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy, (LAANE),
a long-time HERE ally that works to build community support
among low-wage workers all over Los Angeles. UNITE HERE concentrates
on the traditional union battle fronts - rank-and-file support
and negotiations.
LAANE
Deputy Director Vivian Rothstein reels off a list of community
support mobilizations: In one action, some 1,000 workers recently
demonstrated outside the Hyatt and the Century Plaza hotels
while community members went inside the lobby with signs that
urged management to "Listen to your workers' voices."
On Tuesday, a group of African-American elected officials
and ministers exhorted constituents and congregants not to
cross picket lines to take replacement jobs.
Churches,
temples, and community groups are "adopting" individual
hotels with pledges to join workers once a week on picket
lines and collect funds to help supplement the $200-a-week
the union has promised picketing strikers. Over the last year,
at least 45 congregations have pledged support to the workers
at individual hotels, organized by Clergy and Laity United
for Economic Justice. Delegations have made clear that there
will be no receptions, conferences, or bat or bar mitzvahs
held at hotels with unresolved labor troubles.
Labor
is also closing ranks. Mike Farrell, a vice president of the
Screen Actors Guild, and John Connelly, president of the American
Federation of Television and Radio Actors, joined the line-up
of speakers at a UNITE HERE event near MacArthur Park last
week. "It's disheartening once again to hear terms like
'lockout' and 'intimidation'," said Farrell, who vowed
that "SAG will not have any meetings at any of the nine
hotels involved until there is a contract." Connelly
provoked a roar when he declared, "AFTRA members don't
cross picket lines!"
Health
care issues are a central sticking point in the negotiations.
Muir of the hotel council says that employers are offering
full coverage; the union holds that the hotel's proposal doesn't
guarantee that employers will pay for increases.
But
both sides refuse to budge on a seemingly obscure issue: contract
length. Union negotiators in the three cities where a strike
looms want a contract that expires in 2006 so it will align
with hotel contract expirations in seven other cities, maximizing
power for future negotiations. Employers are dead-set against
it.
Union
officials argue that it is the only way to proceed against
operators who have consolidated to the point where five chains
run most of the hotel market. Labor, says David Koff of UNITE
HERE, has to change the rules of engagement to win any gains.
"Manufacturing jobs were transformed from dead-end low-wage
jobs through organizing and in the 1940s and '50s became the
basis of expansion of the middle class."
At
issue now in L.A., he says: "Can the burgeoning service
sector become a path to the middle class?"
More
News About the Los Angeles Hotel Workers' Struggle for a Fair
Contract >>
|