Police
Ticket Drivers for Honking to Support Strikers
San Francisco Chronicle - October 14, 2004
By Jaxon Van Derbeken
Honking
motorists found themselves being pulled over and either ticketed
or issued warnings on Wednesday when they sounded off in support
of San Francisco hotel workers embroiled in a labor dispute.
San
Francisco police issued $50 citations to a dozen motorists
for their sympathetic honking on behalf of picketing hotel
workers at the Palace Hotel on New Montgomery. Many more were
warned verbally and had their license numbers recorded.
Police
Capt. Denis O'Leary said that in answer to complaints about
the racket, he asked the union for the workers to stop holding
signs that urged motorists to "honk for health care''
-- a request they agreed to. But people honked anyway.
O'Leary
said he has received 20 faxed letters from businesses along
New Montgomery near Market Street. "A lot of them are
consultants, therapists, they need to talk to people and they
can't be heard.''
Meanwhile,
in another effort to lower the volume, the Fire Department
banned its crews from sounding air horns in solidarity with
the workers.
Fire
Chief Joanne Hayes-White said the department has received
six complaints this week that crews used horns and sirens
in front of the picketed hotels. Workers struck four hotels
two weeks ago and were then locked out of 14. Hayes-White
said firefighters could be subject to discipline for violating
the policy.
"Obviously
we have to rely on the vehicle code -- we can't take advantage
of our horns and sirens,'' she said. "It's not appropriate,
it's not professional. It's just not conducive to our mission
to take a side or to do something that may be disruptive.''
A
hotel worker on the picket line said Wednesday that people
should have the right to honk in support of the cause.
Harris
Harada, a picket captain for Local 2 of the union at the Palace
Hotel, said police went "a little overboard'' in citing
motorists.
"I
understand people are trying to do their jobs in this area,
but the motorists are just trying to show support to us. They
are giving citations for that? I don't understand.''
O'Leary
said that those who simply tapped on their horns got warnings,
but those who laid on the horn for 30 to 60 seconds got ticketed.
"We
have been citing blatant violators of the vehicle code,''
O'Leary said.
"It's
a two-lane street, surrounded by older buildings -- we have
the same number of picketers on Third Street, Eighth Street
and Market Street, but all the noise complaints are from the
unit block of New Montgomery.''
He
said since the picketers removed the signs and the enforcement
action, the honking was "somewhat diminished.''
One
motorist who was given a warning about using her horn was
angered at what she considered a restriction on her freedom
to support the workers.
"I
gave two little honks on my horn, gave them a thumbs-up in
support the strikers, and as soon as I did so, a cop pulled
me over in the middle of the street,'' said local businesswoman
Laurie Muschel.
The
officer demanded her license and told her she was disturbing
the peace. "You must be kidding,'' she said, but the
officer explained that businesses in the area had been complaining.
"I'm
just shocked -- it feels like my rights were being violated,''
she said. "It just seemed like a tactic to dissuade people
from supporting the strikers. I was not going by laying on
my horn. It was just two little short beeps.''
|