Newsom
Threatens To Picket Hotels
Mayor Applies Pressure To Force Cooling-Off Period
San Francisco Chronicle - October 26, 2004
By Steve Rubenstein and George Raine
San
Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom threatened Monday to join hotel
workers on their picket lines today unless hotel owners end
a four-week lockout and allow employees to return to their
jobs for a 90-day cooling-off period.
Newsom
gave the owners of 14 hotels until 2 p.m. today to respond
to his request. If they refuse to go along with the cooling-off
period, the mayor said he will seek to have the city stop
doing business with the hotels and call for a public boycott.
"If
the lockout does not end, the hotels know where I am going
to position myself -- as an exceedingly strong advocate for
the people out there on the lines, in the rain, through the
holidays, who are the pawns in this," Newsom said. "I'm
a free market, pro-business Democrat, and I'm trying to be
fair here, but my city's being tarnished, and these workers
are being hurt."
Mayoral
spokesman Peter Ragone said the mayor could join pickets as
early as this afternoon.
The
union representing 4,000 locked-out hotel workers -- cooks,
room cleaners, bartenders, bellmen, servers and others --
said they are willing to return to work for a 90-day cooling-off
period. Representatives of the 14 hotels involved in the labor
dispute said they would give the mayor an answer by his deadline.
"We
understand the mayor feels strong about this,'' said Barbara
French, a spokeswoman for the hotels. "We have his request
under advisement.''
On
Sunday, Newsom proposed the cooling-off period in a letter
to Mike Casey, president of Local 2 of the hotel workers union,
Unite Here, and Mark Huntley, president of a group of 14 San
Francisco hotels that is negotiating labor contracts, the
Multi-Employer Group.
The
two are locked in a tense labor dispute that led to a two-week
strike against four of the hotels that began Sept. 29 and
to the eventual lockout of the employees of all 14 hotels
-- more than 4,000 in all. Contract negotiations have been
fruitless.
"The
hotels now have gotten their two weeks in after the two-week
strike,'' the mayor said. "Fair is fair," he said.
As far as I'm concerned, you're even. Now let's all grow up
and get back to work."
In
his letter, Newsom said the continued dispute "causes
significant disruption to the citizens and visitors of our
city, and it threatens to interfere with San Francisco's economic
recovery.''
The
four hotels that the union originally struck were the Argent,
the InterContinental Mark Hopkins, the Hilton and the Crowne
Plaza Union Square. The workers were locked out of those four
plus the Fairmont, Four Seasons, Grand Hyatt, Holiday Inn
Civic Center, Holiday Inn Express & Suites Fisherman's
Wharf, Holiday Inn at Fisherman's Wharf, the Palace Hotel,
Hyatt Regency, Omni and Westin St. Francis.
There
are three conventions this week in San Francisco with a total
of 36,000 people attending. But another major gathering --
more than 5,000 delegates of the American Anthropological
Association scheduled to meet Nov. 17-21 at the San Francisco
Hilton -- might be moved to Atlanta. Organizers of the convention
said Monday they want to learn the response to Newsom's request.
The Hilton is one of the four hotels where workers struck
on Sept. 29 and one of the 14 where the lockout continues.
Casey
wrote to Newsom on Monday saying the union would agree to
send members back to work from Wednesday through Jan. 25 while
negotiations continue. Casey said the return to work would
be unconditional and the union would negotiate on all outstanding
issues.
Spokeswoman
French said Monday the 14 local hotel managers met to discuss
the proposal and are discussing it with their own companies.
"The
hotels believe the solution is an agreement'' reached at the
negotiating table, she said. "They appreciate and respect
the mayor's continued involvement.''
Ultimately,
Newsom's authority in the matter is limited to his power of
persuasion and the prestige of his office, but San Francisco's
losses could be considerable in a prolonged labor dispute.
The cancellation of major conventions -- and the subsequent
loss of tourist dollars -- is still possible.
The
American Anthropological Association made reservations for
its 2004 annual meeting at the Hilton eight years ago, said
Elizabeth Brumfiel, the association president and professor
of anthropology at Northwestern University. On Friday, she
and the group's executive board sent an e-mail to members
saying that, because of the labor dispute, the board had voted
to move the meeting from San Francisco to the Atlanta Hilton,
Dec. 15-19.
On
learning Monday morning of Newsom's overture, the group suspended
those plans pending the response from both the union and the
hotels, said Brumfiel. Monday, she e-mailed members telling
not to cancel or make new reservations until it's decided
where to hold the meeting.
However,
both sides' agreeing to a cooling-off period today would not
automatically translate to a decision to keep the meeting
in San Francisco. It may be impossible to change back from
the plan to shift to Atlanta, as members began making changes
to their itinerary at week's end, Brumfiel said, adding that
a final decision about the venue would come today.
The
group sides ideologically with the union, and Brumfiel has
written that "anthropologists cannot, in all good conscience,
meet in facilities whose owners are using the lockout of low-wage
workers as a bargaining tactic.''
The
group had a legal vulnerability, too, as breaking the Hilton
contract would expose the members to potential damages of
$1.2 million -- the fee for renting the hotel facilities.
The association and Hilton worked out a tentative compromise,
said Brumfiel -- go to Atlanta, a nonunion hotel, this year
but return to San Francisco in 2006.
However,
Debbie Larkin, a spokeswoman for the hotel, said, "Our
understanding is that (the anthropologists' meeting) is still
going to be here.''
By
calculations of the San Francisco Convention & Visitors
Bureau, the 5,000-plus anthropologists would probably spend
$3,093,750 in the city.
In
2003, 14 million visitors spent $6.3 billion at local businesses,
and conventioneers spent close to 60 percent of the total,
the rest coming from leisure and business travelers, said
Mark Theis, the bureau's convention manager.
John
Marks, who heads the bureau, said he thinks both the union
and the hotels will have to find an incentive to participate
in a cooling-off period. "There has to be some blue sky,
some potential win for both sides,'' he said. "You don't
want to play nice for three months. That's no big victory.''
Notwithstanding
the dispute, there are 6,000 people attending the Mortgage
Bankers Association meeting this week, 12,000 at the Cellular
Telecommunications and Internet Association meeting, and 18,000
at the Audio Engineering Society meeting beginning Thursday,
said Marks.
Chronicle
staff writer Wyatt Buchanan contributed to this report.
|