Convention
Moved to San Jose Because of S.F. Hotel Labor Strife
San Jose Mercury News - February 19, 2005
By Mary Anne Ostrom
As
San Francisco's hotel labor strife drags on into its seventh
month, San Jose is convention hunting.
And
they've snagged one. The Organization of American Historians
and its 2,000 participants are canceling their San Francisco
Hilton affair and moving it to San Jose in late March. Although
it is considered a small convention, it could mean as much
as $2 million in business for the city.
``We're
not being shy,'' said Dan Fenton, president and chief executive
of San Jose Convention & Visitors Bureau. Fenton added
that he tells conventioneers in his pitch that San Jose is
labor-friendly.
After
their contract at 14 union hotels expired in August and talks
broke down with the employers, the workers went on strike
at four San Francisco hotels in late September. The owners
quickly responded by locking workers out of all 14.
San
Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom helped negotiate a 60-day cooling-off
period around the holidays, and the workers returned. That
period expired in mid-January and there has not been much
progress. Hotel workers remain on the job.
This
week, Unite Here Local 2, which represents 4,300 employees
at 14 of San Francisco's largest hotels, began one-day pickets
at selected hotels.
San
Jose union officials have been working with their San Francisco
colleagues to help identify conventions and meetings in San
Francisco hotels where union contracts have expired, said
Fenton. And then, Fenton's bureau contacts those conventioneers,
asking if they'd like to try San Jose.
With
the hockey season apparently canceled, Fenton said every little
bit helps.
Fenton
said his convention and visitors bureau knew the historians
had to pay a cancellation fee to the San Francisco Hilton,
and that some of its members had already booked their flights
to San Francisco International. To entice them, Fenton said
the cost structure took into account the hotel cancellation
fee, but his group did not pay the penalty directly.
Fenton's
bureau is also providing shuttle service from San Francisco
International for those who cannot change their flights.
Mike
Casey, who leads the Unite Here employee group, said, ``We're
definitely calling conventions and telling them to get out
of the union hotels, but not San Francisco.''
Casey
warned the historians they could expect to cross a picket
line if they stayed at the Hilton.
In
San Jose, conventioneers will stay predominantly at the San
Jose Hyatt and Doubletree hotels for their meeting, which
runs from March 31 to April 3.
A
spokesman for the San Francisco hotel employer group, which
includes the San Francisco Hilton, declined comment. He would
say only that the owners are hoping to have a contract soon.
But
John Marks, president of the San Francisco Convention &
Visitors Bureau, said he is somewhat concerned about San Jose's
tactics, particularly if they involve paying the group's cancellation
penalty.
``At
what point do you meet the ethical question of trying to become
a predator, trying to prey on someone else's business? I have
a little bit of concern about that,'' said Marks. ``It is
a fine line.''
|